Now that one-third of the NFL schedule is complete, there is sufficient team data present to start some statistical trend analysis on the 2009 NFL season. My goal is to see which statistics are the best predictors of success in the regular reason and in the playoffs/SuperBowl.
First Up: Turnover Difference
As you can see from the pink shaded percentages, positive turnover difference is a very sound predictor of regular and post season success in the NFL over the past four seasons. Teams with a positive turnover differential made the playoffs 77% of the time from 2005-2008. 88% of SuperBowl participants between 2005-2008 had a positive turnover differential and 3 of the 4 SuperBowl Champions since 2005 have had a positive turnover differential. These results seems to signify a definite trend, but it only measures the past 4 years. Let's take a look at what happens when data from the 1999-2004 and 2005-2008 seasons are combined:

Primary Conclusion - It is rare for a team to win the SuperBowl if they turned the ball over more than they took it away in the regular season - 90% of SuperBowl teams from 1999-2008 had a positive turnover differential.
***Only once in the past 10 years has a team been able to win the SuperBowl with a negative turnover differential in the regular season (NY Giants beating the 18-0 NE Patriots in 2007).
Secondary Conclusion: Turnover differential is a solid predictor of regular season success in the NFL - 72% of playoff teams from 1999-2008 had a positive turnover differential.
In an attempt to predict which teams will have success this year, primary conclusions will be used to eliminate teams from SuperBowl contention. Teams with a negative turnover differential have been marked in the data table with an "X" and will no longer be considered as a possible SuperBowl winner.
Eliminated Teams* - Panthers, Browns, Cowboys, Bears, Lions, Dolphins, Raiders, Seahawks, Rams, Bucs, Titans, Redskins, and Steelers
*It is very possible that teams with a negative turnover differential around -1 to -3 could change their ways and be removed from the eliminated teams list if they start generating more positive turnovers.
Next step, using historical defensive statistics to eliminate a set of the remaining 19 teams from SuperBowl contention...