Current (Typical) 2011 Orioles Lineup:
1. Hardy (SS)
2. Markakis (RF)
3. Jones (CF)
4. Guerrero (DH)
5. Wieters (C)
6. Lee (1B)
7. Scott (LF)
8. Reynolds (3B)
9. Andino (2B)
As you can probably see, this is not a terrible lineup on paper if you use their 2010 individual statistics. The problem is a very simple one - the Orioles current lineup is league average in every shape and form. The proof is in the numbers. See below for a comparison of the 2011 Orioles lineup to the 2011 American League "League Averages" as of June 23rd, 2011:
As of June 23rd, 2011 | AVG | OBP | SLG | OPS |
2011 AL "League Average" | 0.254 | 0.321 | 0.395 | 0.717 |
2011 Orioles | 0.259 | 0.321 | 0.393 | 0.714 |
It's pretty apparent by looking at those numbers that the 2011 Baltimore Orioles lineup is ordinary and league average. I do not foresee these numbers changing dramatically over the rest of the season either. The Orioles will probably end 2011 as a league average offensive team. This would not be frowned upon as much if the Orioles were in the NL
West Weak, but the
AL bEAST will be their home for the immediate and near future, so league average is not acceptable.
The Orioles Front Office has a prime opportunity this off-season to create a formidable AL East-type lineup by signing one player:
Prince Fielder. To start, a lot of the expensive dead weight in this lineup (Lee, Vlad, maybe Scott) will no longer be under contract by the start of 2012. My hope and belief is that
Andy McPhail Peter Angelos will use the money from those expiring contracts to make a serious contract offer to Fielder. I know the idea of the Orioles signing Prince Fielder is not a new one (see articles
1,
2, and
3), but it's the most direct and easy way, in my opinion for the Orioles to compete in 2012. Here is the possible 2012 lineup with Fielder being the only off-season acquisition:
1. Hardy (SS) - I know it's going to be difficult for the O's to keep him (going to command 8-12 MM).
2. Markakis (RF) - His diminished power keeps him in the 2nd spot. Still a .300 hitter in my opinion.
3. Jones (CF) - He would see lots of strikes with Fielder behind him.
4. Fielder (1B) - No comment is really necessary, pure power-hitter that produces runs consistently (1.033 OPS in 2011 - no other Oriole is in his ballpark).
5. Wieters (C) - Awesome with RISP (frequent opportunities with Fielders' average of 20 IBBs a year in front of him)
6. Reimold (DH) - High OBP + High SLG = Offensive Production
7. Reynolds (3B) - Must keep him lower in lineup due to strikeouts (rally-killer). See Reimold Comment.
8. Pie (LF) - This could be Luke Scott, but either way, it's a weak position where a Free Agent could help.
9. Roberts (2B) - I still have faith that he can be productive again (needs to take the rest of 2011 off).
I know this lineup is far from perfect (signing a productive 2B or LFer would push it closer to elite status). From my perspective, the top of the lineup cannot get much better unless they decide to start spending like the Yanks/Soxs. But I have serious concerns about the 6-9 spots...
I'm a major Reimold apologist/supporter, so I'm probably being too generous with his potential as a quality DH/LF. Any lineup with Reynolds in the 7 spot is okay by me. Problem is, Reynolds defense (16 errors as of June 23rd) is so atrocious that it cancels out all of the valuable stuff he accomplishes at the plate (.350 OBP and .462 SLG for 2011). Pie would be servicable as a #8 hitter, but he lacks the power (.302 SLG for 2011) and patience (.252 OBP for 2011) of even an average major league player. Roberts (or Adams/Andino) is perfectly suited for the 9 spot with plus on-base skills (.353 career OBP) and speed.
This mock 2012 lineup is not perfect, but it's a far cry from the past and the addition of an impact bat is something the Orioles have not had in at least a decade. This projected 2012 lineup coupled with a healthy, progressing starting rotation could lead to an exciting 2012 season. I'm going out on a limb, but I think the Orioles will win 88-90 games next year, but only
IF (
big IF) they sign Prince Fielder.
Go O's!! Bring back The Orioles Way!!